The Intolerance of Tolerance

The Intolerance of Tolerance

D.A. Carson’s latest book hits this contemporary issue head on. An excerpt:

The sad reality is that this new, contemporary tolerance is intrinsically intolerant. It is blind to its own shortcomings because it erroneously thinks it holds the moral high ground; it cannot be questioned because it has become part of the West’s plausibility structure. Worse, this new tolerance is socially dangerous and is certainly intellectually debilitating.

[Carson then compares an older definition of tolerance with a newer one]

“ACCEPT EXISTENCE OF DIFFERENT VIEWS to recognize other people’s right to have different beliefs or practices without an attempt to suppress them.” So far so good.

When we turn to Encarta’s treatment of the corresponding noun “tolerance,” however, a subtle change appears: “ACCEPTANCE OF DIFFERENT VIEWS the accepting of the differing views of other people.

This shift from “accepting the existence of different views” to “acceptance of different views,” from recognizing other people’s right to have different beliefs or practices to accepting the differing views of other people, is subtle in form, but massive in substance. To accept that a different or opposing position exists and deserves the right to exist is one thing; to accept the position itself means that one is no longer opposing it. The new tolerance suggests that actually accepting another’s position means believing that position to be true, or at least as true as your own. We move from allowing the free expression of contrary opinions to the acceptance of all opinions; we leap from permitting the articulation of beliefs and claims with which we do not agree to asserting that all beliefs and claims are equally valid. Thus we slide from the old tolerance to the new.

Christians do think that Jesus is the only way to God. But does that make them intolerant? In the former sense of “intolerant,” not at all; the fact remains, however, that any sort of exclusive truth claim is widely viewed as a sign of gross intolerance. But the latter depends absolutely on the second meaning of “tolerance.”

D. A. Carson. The Intolerance of Tolerance. © Grand Rapids: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Co. 2012. Pages 2-6.

You can read more at the Gospel Coalition Site.

http://thegospelcoalition.org/blogs/tgc/2012/02/26/contemporary-tolerance-is-intrinsically-intolerant/